Monday, September 23, 2019

Greatest QBs of the Super Bowl Era: No. 48 - Billy Kilmer

Billy Kilmer is another late bloomer who played his way onto this list once he got into the right situation.

Kilmer was a lightly regarded prospect who went from one year of junior college football to fifth in the Heisman voting by his senior season at UCLA. He was the 11th pick of the first round by the San Francisco 49ers in 1961 who plugged him in as a running quarterback in a shotgun system.

The 49ers saw no future for Kilmer as a quarterback, who rarely threw a tight spiral. San Francisco played him primarily at running back until placing him in the 1967 expansion draft. The New Orleans Saints picked Kilmer and finally gave him a chance at a starting job. He shared the QB duties for two seasons before taking over fulltime in 1969.

The year, Kilmer finished in the top 10 in approximate value. After the 1970 season, Kilmer knew the Saints were going to draft Archie Manning and asked for a trade. He got his wish, as the Washington Redskins sent a linebacker and two draft picks to Washington.

In Washington, Kilmer was slated to be a backup to Sonny Jurgenson. Jurgenson injured his shoulder before the start of the season and Kilmer grabbed the starting job and wouldn't give it up until 1978 when he was 39 years old.

As a Redskin, Kilmer finished in the top 10 in approximate value four times and passer rating five times. That included a second-place finish in 1972 when the Redskins made it to the Super Bowl, where they lost to the undefeated Dolphins. Kilmer was a clutch playoff passer, finishing in the top five in passer rating four times.

Billy Kilmer
Season Playoffs
Year Team AV PR DYAR QBR Avg. PR QBR Avg. Total
1969 New Orleans Saints 4 0 X X 2.00 0 X 0 2.00
1971 Washington Redskins 1 3 X X 2.00 1 X 1 3.00
1972 Washington Redskins 2.5 9 X X 5.75 3 X 3 8.75
1973 Washington Redskins 0 4 X X 2.00 2 X 2 4.00
1974 Washington Redskins 2 5 X X 3.50 0 X 0 3.50
1975 Washington Redskins 0.5 2 X X 1.25 0 X 0 1.25
1976 Washington Redskins 0 0 X X 0.00 2 X 0 2.00
Total 24.50
Best 5 (1969, 1971, 1972, 1973, 1974) 21.25
JAWS Score 22.88

Top QBs of the Super Bowl Era
Rank Quarterback Years Total Top 5 JAWS
48 Billy Kilmer 1969-1976 24.50 21.25 22.88
49 Joe Namath 1966-1974 23.50 22.00 22.75
50 Vinny Testaverde 1993-2001 22.67 22.67 22.67
51 Daunte Culpepper 2000-2004 22.17 22.17 22.17
52 Ron Jaworski 1978-1983 21.21 20.38 20.79
53 Neil Lomax 1983-1988 20.59 20.59 20.59
54 Jim Plunkett 1971-1986 20.59 18.09 19.34

No comments: